NIPAC Blog #3: Big Names Fall Again

by the Steward
Sunday, March 1, 2009 – “In that way it resembles the basketball championships,” said one of the judges, a well-traveled IPA geek based in Detroit, Michigan. “Small teams can come out of nowhere and beat the big names.”
Big names indeed. The results of the 2nd round of the National IPA Championships had just been announced and the last of the Final Four from 2008 had succumbed, leaving the field open to others to make their name in the quest for the best IPA of 2009. Along with the fall of that last FF2008 contestant, Bell’s Two-Hearted Ale, went the rest of Michigan’s entries. This in a judging that took place on their home turf, replete with Michigan-based judges. Crooked Tree, Centennial, Mad Hatter, this was the year of the upsets.
But don’t tell that to the beers that advanced. Coming from all around the country, these beers have bested some of the best in head to head competition. And they’ve done it with a superb combination of water, yeast, malt and hops. Especially the hops.
There are some big battles looming. Clipper City’s Loose Cannon, a stellar example of aromatic and tasty hops buttressed by a mean dose of bitterness goes against the giant killer, Big Dog’s Hop Harvest Ale, which knocked off last year’s champ. If there is a dark horse to go all the way, Hop Harvest is probably that beer.
Another new entry, Laurelwood’s Workhorse IPA, is also a monstrously good beer and likely to battle its way to the final. And don’t count out Marin and Moylan’s IPAs, both stellar examples of bitterness, balance and flavor. Last year both of those beers got knocked out in the first round but this year they have roared back to show their cone-jones.
I don’t mean to dis any of the unmentioned contestants, but this brings up a good point. As a person who travels the country tasting great beers (especially IPAs, my beer of choice), I haven’t sample all of the contestants so don’t know how to glorify them. The competition has been a great way to learn about new beers. Who would have thought Montana would produce such a giant as Big Sky’s IPA? And two beers from Kansas in the Sweet Sixteen? They’re not in Kansas anymore, Dorothy!
While it would be easy to question the results from even this group of stellar hophead judges, it’s smarter yet to discover that there are brewers in places beyond California, Oregon and Michigan brewing kick-ass beers and taking no names. This competition reminds me of the need to travel and taste, and to continue to learn about the beers and the brewers behind them all over the U.S.
So onward to the Sweet Sixteen round, to be held this weekend in Philadelphia. Let the better IPA advance and let us open our taste buds to the sweet taste of hops.

3 Responses to “NIPAC Blog #3: Big Names Fall Again”

  1. Greg Veal says:

    Yes, there are some shocking upsets. (Pretty much tosses me out of the running unless everyone else is even FARTHER out.)

    But I can give you a good reason for the surprises. I consider myself a fairly discriminating beer drinker. I enjoy most styles, really love a few, and have a few beers that I always have on hand. But I’ve noticed, as have many craft beer lovers, that the style or particular beer that will “hit the spot” for me can change from day to day. And some days, even my favorite beers just don’t do it for me.

    But then, you say, I’m not a certified beer judge. OK, but I have been around beer judging (as a steward) enough to know that while these judges really know their stuff, their tastes can vary day-to-day, hour-to-hour even. Beer judging is definitely an art, not a perfect science. And I’d be willing to bet, if these judges rejudged the exact same beers a month later, the results would be wildly different.

    Now, I don’t mean to take away the fun. I think this is a great event and I’m having fun following it. I have very little stake in the results (unless I actually win!!! : ) but I’ll be happy to celebrate the winner. And I will surely seek out the final four for a tasting. Here’s to hops!

  2. LUIS says:


    Medicamentspot.com. Canadian Health&Care.Special Internet Prices.No prescription online pharmacy.Best quality drugs. High quality drugs. Buy pills online

    Buy:Nexium.Mega Hoodia.Synthroid.Accutane.100% Pure Okinawan Coral Calcium.Zovirax.Prevacid.Valtrex.Arimidex.Actos.Prednisolone.Retin-A.Zyban.Lumigan.Human Growth Hormone.Petcam (Metacam) Oral Suspension….